Taylor Swift v. Luke in MN

She is young, rich, and famous. I am less young, less rich, and less famous, but have a more stable personal life and a less annoying tendency of singing about it. It's a close battle.

The only way to break the tie is this: Which wins? A team of MLB players older than Luke in MN or a team of players younger than Taylor Swift?

I am 34.5. T-Swizzle is 23.

This is my team:

Position Player Bday WAR
C A.J. Pierzynski 12/30/1976 2.3
1B Paul Konerko 3/5/1976 2.4
2B Mark Ellis 6/6/1977 1.4
SS Derek Jeter 6/26/1974 2.0
3B Aramis Ramirez 6/25/1978 3.6
LF Alfonso Soriano 1/7/1976 1.9
CF Andres Torres 1/26/1978 1.7
RF Torii Hunter 7/18/1975 2.8
DH David Ortiz 11/18/1975 3.1
IF Rafael Furcal 10/24/1977 1.5
IF Clint Barmes 3/6/1979 1.5
C Miguel Olivo 7/15/1978 1.6
OF Carlos Beltran 4/24/1977 2.2
SP Cliff Lee 8/30/1978 5.7
SP Roy Halladay 5/14/1977 4.5
SP Kyle Lohse 10/4/1978 3.1
SP Tim Hudson 7/14/1975 2.5
SP Ryan Vogelsong 2/10/1975 2.5
CL J.J. Putz 2/22/1977 1.0
SETUP Octavio Dotel 11/25/1973 0.8
SETUP-L Matt Thornton 9/15/1976 0.6
RP Grant Balfour 12/30/1977 0.7
RP Jason Grilli 11/11/1976 0.8
RP-L Darren Oliver 10/6/1970 0.4
Long R.A. Dickey* (SP) 10/29/1974 2.4

I used ZIPS WAR projections for 2013. Because I am just that old, Chase Utley, Jimmy Rollins, and Adrian Beltre all just missed the age cutoff. Still, it's a pretty strong team, especially the pitching.

Here is Tay's team:

Position Player Bday WAR
C Salvador Perez 5/10/1990 3.3
1B Manny Machado* (3b) 7/6/1992 2.7
2B Henry Rodriguez 2/9/1990 1.2
SS Jurickson Profar 2/20/1993 3.7
3B Starlin Castro* (SS) 3/24/1990 3.9
LF Bryce Harper 10/16/1992 4.7
CF Mike Trout 8/7/1991 7.4
RF Anthony Gose 8/10/1990 2.2
DH Brett Lawrie* (3b) 1/18/1990 4.5
IF Jean Segura 3/1/1990 2.4
IF Jose Altuve 5/6/1990 2.4
C Gary Sanchez 12/2/1992 1.7
OF Rafael Ortega 5/15/1991 1.3
SP Shelby Miller 10/10/1990 2
SP Jordon Lyles 10/19/1990 1.6
SP Erasmo Ramirez 5/2/1990 1.6
SP Joe Wieland 12/1/1990 1.5
SP Trevor Rosenthal 5/29/1990 1.4
CL Kelvin Herrera 12/31/1989 0.7
SETUP Dylan Bundy* (SP) 11/15/1992 0.6
SETUP-L Paco Rodriguez 4/16/1991 0.3
RP Henderson Alvarez* (S) 4/18/1990 0.5
RP Carter Capps 8/7/1990 0.1
RP-L Martin Perez* (SP) 4/4/1991 0.4
Long Trevor Bauer* (SP) 1/17/1991 1.2

These guys really are kids. Giancarlo Stanton, Jason Heyward, Jesus Montero, Eric Hosmer? Too old. Elvis Andrus, Stephen Strasburg, Mike Moustakas, Chris Sale? Way too old.

I have to hand it to Taylor, it's still a good team. Brett Lawrie and Manny Machado are going to be a bit wasted at DH and 1B and the pitching is not stellar, but the position players are stunning.

So, who gets the win Twinkie Town?

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Twinkie Town

You must be a member of Twinkie Town to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Twinkie Town. You should read them.

Join Twinkie Town

You must be a member of Twinkie Town to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Twinkie Town. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.