Angel Hernandez Gets A Performance Review

Thearon W. Henderson

He's widely known as baseball's worst umpire. I wonder what his yearly performance reviews look like?

SCENE: A nondescript office in New York. MLB Director of Umpires RANDY MARSH sits at a conference room table, shuffling papers in and out of a briefcase and whistling mostly tunelessly, though a sharp-eared listener may be able to detect occasional strains of "Take Me Out To The Ballgame."

A soft knock, and then the door opens. In walks ANGEL HERNANDEZ.

HERNANDEZ: Hey, Randy. We doing this in the conference room this year?

MARSH: Yep, we sure are. Good to see you. This won't take a minute, but we got to do these - you know paperwork.

HERNANDEZ: Sure, sure.

MARSH: Let's get going, then. The old man is prowling around today and I don't want him stopping -

The door opens with a crash, accompanied by a thump from outside the room. Both men jump to their feet.

BUD SELIG: Dang it, I thought this was one of them newfangled sliding glass doors!

MARSH: Told you a hundred times, Mr. Selig. Those are only on the outside of buildings. In here we have regular doors.

SELIG: Ah, dangit. Well, anyway, I heard that Angel here was coming in today for his performance review, since his crew is in town. Was hoping I could sit in. You just go ahead and run through your questions.

MARSH (looking uncomfortable): Uh... you sure maybe you don't want to ask your questions first? Don't want to hold you up here.

SELIG: No, no, this is the main thing I got to do today. Already finished the Jumble.

MARSH: Right... all right, question 1. Are you still breathing regularly?


MARSH: Were you a major league umpire previously?


MARSH: All right, that wraps it up for our questions. According to my sliding scale, your performance rating for this year is "Outstanding."

HERNANDEZ: Thank you.

SELIG (jumps up, knocking a computer to the floor): Now just hold on a minute here! You mean to say that's the whole performance review?

MARSH: We've been using it for years, and it never failed us before.

SELIG: Does anyone ever not get "outstanding"?

HERNANDEZ: Eric Gregg got "super-outstanding" eight years in a row.


MARSH: He ate an entire meatball sub without using his hands.

HERNANDEZ (puts his hand on his heart): The man had a gift.

SELIG: Well, blast it, I'm not going to let this go by. Sit back down, I've got a few questions of my own!

MARSH: Neither of us got up. You're the only one that's standing up.

SELIG (staring wildly): Right. Alright, question one, smart guy. If a fielder throws his glove at the ball and hits it, what happens?

HERNANDEZ: Uh... The batter gets a ground-rule double?

SELIG (to Marsh): Is he right?

MARSH: How should I know?

SELIG: I'll look it up later. OK, question two. Is this a balk? He waves his arms around wildly while sticking his tongue out and making goofy faces


SELIG: Wrong answer! Trick question, I wasn't the pitcher, I was the third baseman.

MARSH: That's just silly.

HERNANDEZ: Don't worry, I've got this. He winds up dramatically. All right, you're outta this game!

SELIG: What game?

MARSH (gently): Angel, you can't really-

HERNANDEZ: Nope, you're gone! Start walking!

SELIG: Or what?

HERNANDEZ: Or I'll have to make a report and send it to the commissioner's office!

SELIG: You're in the commissioner's office. That's literally where we are right now.

HERNANDEZ: Oh. Well, maybe, then... um...

MARSH (again, gently): Angel, why don't you just go. I'll take care of this.

HERNANDEZ: Right. Yes. Well. He leaves, somewhat huffily.

SELIG: Randy, that man needs to be fired!

MARSH: Yeah, I know.

SELIG: You're not going to fire him, are you?

MARSH: No, I'm not. And do you know why I'm not?

SELIG: Because after years of being an umpire, you hate everything and everyone?

MARSH: That's right.

SELIG: Me too.

We zoom away, with both men looking pensive. In the far distance, we can hear Hernandez attempting to eject two secretaries, a doorman, and a cab driver.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Twinkie Town

You must be a member of Twinkie Town to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Twinkie Town. You should read them.

Join Twinkie Town

You must be a member of Twinkie Town to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Twinkie Town. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.