clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Twins 5, Rangers 4: Alexi Casilla Helps Twins Walk Off to Seventh Win In Eight Games

Getty Images

Last night's win didn't come without drama. The drama of a walk off win, of course, but also the drama of questionable calls by the umpires. It was the second questionable call of the evening that may have sealed the fate of the game.

With the game tied at four, Luke Hughes led off the bottom of the ninth with a double down the left field line. There was some controversy on the call, however.


You can see the ball at the very top middle of the screen shot, above what is Luke's left heel. By this point the ball had already bounced off of the chalk line separating fair and foul territory, and at approximately this point the ball is bouncing directly over third base. Adrian Beltre and the Rangers refused to believe the ball was fair, even after the game, but if this ball is directly over third base then I'm compelled to call it a fair ball.

From MLB's Official Rule Book:

"A FAIR BALL is a batted ball that settles on fair ground between home and first base, or between home and third base, or that is on or over fair territory when bounding to the outfield past first or third base, or that touches first, second or third base, or that first falls on fair territory on or beyond first base or third base, or that, while on or over fair territory touches the person of an umpire or player, or that, while over fair territory, passes out of the playing field in flight."

I've emphasized the portion that I think appeals to this play in italics. If the ball is over the base, then it's a fair ball. Even if the first contact with the grass beyond the base is in foul territory. Feel free to correct me, because I'm no Judge Judy and Executioner, but that's how I've interpreted this.

More after the jump.

I won't argue that Rene Rivera was actually out on second base in the fifth inning. Elvis Andrus fielded Matt Tolbert's sharp grounder, tagged Rivera (who had to stop to make sure the ball wasn't caught) and then threw onto first base. A correct call would have place Tolbert on first base with just one out.

As it played out Rivera was incorrectly called safe, and two outs later Michael Cuddyer went boom. Cuddyer's eighth homer of the year put the Twins up 4-1.

You can never assume a series events when entering an alternate timeline, but had Rivera been correctly called out at second base the inning definitely would have played out differently. Maybe Cuddyer still hits a home run, maybe before he gets a chance the Twins are retired on a double play the very next pitch, or maybe Ben Revere scores Tolbert from first on a double. We can't say.

The Twins were granted a couple of favors on Thursday night, and as much as I don't blame Rangers fans for potentially being upset about the outcome of the game as a result, I am taking every single bounce that goes our way right now. All season long, every single bounce has gone against the Twins. We were due a couple of bounces to go our way. Sorry, Texas.

Nick Blackburn turned in a solid performance, pitching 7.1 innings and allowing four runs (just two earned) while striking out...six? Really? Huh. Apart from Jose Mijares facing two batters and allowing two hits, the bullpen did its job again. Alex Burnett and Chuck James bailed out Mijares, and James combined with Jim Hoey to pitch a scoreless ninth. That set the place for Minnesota's walk off win.

Hughes chopped his double down the left field line to lead off the frame. Mark Lowe struck out pinch hitter Brian Dinkelman before walking Tolbert, at which point the Rangers went to Arthur Rhodes with out one and runners on first and second. Ben Revere would fly out for out number two, but then came Casilla.

After the game Casilla admitted he was looking for a pitch to pull, and that's exactly what he did. Batting right handed Casilla took a 2-1 slider over the lower part of the plate and pulled it over Beltre's head and into the corner for what would have been extra bases. Hughes scored easily to end it.


  • Cuddyer's 8th homer was his first multi-run home of the season. His first seven were all solo shots, which Cuddyer jokingly alluded to in the post-game.
  • Over six appearances from May 9th to May 29th, Jim Hoey allowed nine runs in five innings. In the middle of that he was sent down. But since May 29th, Hoey has pitched three scoreless innings over three appearances. He has three walks to go with his three strikeouts, but he also hasn't allowed a hit.
  • Chuck James has now pitched five innings for the Twins, striking out and walking two while allowing one hit and no runs.
  • Delmon Young hit a home run, a line drive that went about six rows back in left field.
  • Young picked up a trio of hits, and joined Cuddyer and Casilla with multi-hit games.
  • Blackburn's success last night was typical Blackburn. He worked ahead frequently and stayed ahead, turned what few hitter's counts there were into outs, didn't get into long battles, just threw strikes.


Michael Cuddyer: Two hits including a three-run bomb, .307 WPA
Alexi Casilla: Two hits including the walk off, .309 WPA
Chuck James: 0.2 IP, the first out finished a critical top of the eighth, leaving the bases loaded