clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

The Dodgers should pony up, not the Twins

This Betts-Maeda-Graterol trade is a mess, but there is no way the Twins should give up two top-ten prospects for the return.

Divisional Series - Minnesota Twins v New York Yankees - Game One Photo by Brace Hemmelgarn/Minnesota Twins/Getty Images

The Boston Red Sox are derailing their giant Mookie Betts trade by not googling “Brusdar Graterol” before they agreed to the deal. It’s not like there are a lot of other guys by that name playing in the MLB. Still, if the medical report did turn up something that made the Red Sox devalue Graterol, I don’t mind the Twins substituting in another prospect. That isn’t what Heyman is reporting though:

If the Red Sox were asking for a different top ten prospect, then the Twins should be the ones on the hook to meet that price. Graterol for Maeda is a reasonable trade. Graterol plus another top ten prospect for Maeda is lunacy. The Twins are right for holding their ground on this point.

The Red Sox also have a valid point: if Graterol isn’t as valuable as they thought, then they need more value in the trade. That’s where the Dodgers need to step in. The Dodgers are receiving the most value in this trade. They’re getting Mookie Betts and David Price, and only giving up money (which they basically have a license to print) plus Alex Verdugo and Kenta Maeda. That’s an absolute steal. If the Red Sox need another top-ten prospect added, the Dodgers should be the ones to do it.

Again according to Heyman (worth a small bit of salt, but better than Nightengale,) the Dodgers and Red Sox are also discussing other ways to complete the deal, so hopefully this is one of their thoughts.

The Red Sox and the Dodgers both have more to lose in this trade than the Twins do. If things reset to last week, I’m reasonably confident in the Twins rotation still. Maeda does make them better, but its a few marginal wins. He’s just another cog in the quantity over quality strategy at this point.

So, all this goes back to the Dodgers and Red Sox need to work this out, if the Red Sox still want Graterol plus more value. The Twins should hold their ground. A top ten prospect for a starting pitcher. If the Twins need to give up another prospect, the Dodgers should send another player to Minnesota. Otherwise, skip the middleman and send Boston a prospect. Or just let the Twins out, but quit leveraging them to overpay. They shouldn’t and hopefully won’t.

If Boston was being reasonable, the deal could get done with Jorge Alcala or Jhoan Duran instead, and/or maybe another low level prospect. Asking for two top-ten prospects just smacks of Boston seeing the fan reaction to the deal, and deciding to get more. Graterol’s medical report just feels like a convenient excuse to do so. If this is how Chaim Bloom operates, I hope the Twins are never willing to engage in trade talks with him again.